Numerous blowout video video games. A 6-2 group lacking out on the playoff lower. No sudden deaths.
The 18-team model on the Brier has truly had its share of doubters although 6 stable teams made it to the playoff spherical at Prospera Place in Kelowna, B.C.
Six- time Brier champ Brad Gushue went one motion moreover after round-robin play wrapped up by recommending that switch– a much-criticized credentials spherical that was simply made use of for a few years– be considered as soon as once more.
“I think it would be worth a discussion,” Gushue acknowledged. “I’m not advocating for it however I believe that’s the most suitable choice that’s been shared with me that will get us again to that full round-robin that I used to like taking part in and I believe the followers (beloved).
“It obtains the most effective groups there. It’s worth speaking about.”
Relegation format
In the relegation format, which Curling Canada referred to as a ” pre-qualifying” stage when it was used from 2015-17, the 4 lowest-seeded provinces and territories performed a round-robin.
The winner would attain the principle draw and the three shedding groups would go dwelling. Longtime Northwest Territories ladies’s skip Kerry Galusha weighed in on the topic on X, the platform previously referred to as Twitter.
“As somebody that joined all 3 years of transfer it made us function tougher and improve, not claiming it’s the response yet we are visiting unbalanced ready years ahead up until the Northern groups begin functioning tougher and taking a trip extra. I recognized what we needed to do.”
Curling Canada moved to a 16-team setup for the Brier and the Scotties Tournament of Hearts in 2018. The defending champion and all provincial and territorial winners got direct entry together with a wild-card crew.
Two swimming pools of eight groups had been utilized in a format that has since expanded to 18 groups with three pre-qualified entries primarily based on the earlier season’s rankings.
Format debate discovered one other gear this previous week when Northern Ontario’s John Epping and Manitoba’s Reid Carruthers completed tied for third place of their pool at 6-2.
Their head-to-head file was the tiebreaker, leaving Epping on the surface regardless that a 5-3 crew from the opposite pool — Nova Scotia’s Owen Purcell — made the lower.
“It’s odd to play a Brier and it’s a double-knockout,” Epping mentioned.
Supporters really feel the format creates extra depth within the early going. The cutoff for the Friday qualifying video games forward of the Page playoffs heightens mid-week drama.
Top rinks nonetheless play exhausting as a result of seeding and hammer are on the road. At the identical time, a number of groups within the discipline have basically no probability towards the well-funded, well-travelled powerhouse rinks.
“We’re attempting to make everyone delighted and we’re not making anyone delighted,” mentioned Brent Laing, who coached Mike McEwen’s Saskatchewan facet. “It’s a little bit of a mess.”
‘It’s by no means excellent’
Darren Moulding, who coached Thomas Scoffin’s Yukon crew, mentioned rating imbalance within the swimming pools may also be an element. He famous that generally in professional leagues just like the NHL, MLB or the NFL, a crew with a mediocre file can sneak into the playoffs.
“In sporting activities, it’s never ever excellent,” he mentioned. “If you alter the style to make that not take place, there’s mosting likely to be something else that you compromise.”
Nunavut’s Shane Latimer and Aaron Bartling of the Northwest Territories each went 0-8 in round-robin play.
Bartling was dumped 20-2 in his second recreation and gave up a mean of just about 11 factors a recreation. Latimer, in the meantime, was outscored 83-25 over his eight losses.
” I don’t see with the means it’s presently structured simply the way it aids these lower-ranked teams forward in proper right here and acquire burnt out,” mentioned former Curling Canada occasion supervisor Warren Hansen. ” I acknowledge it’s an enormous journey for an excessive amount of them (to be proper right here).
“But I can’t really see myself enjoying coming into this venue and this setting and getting completely annihilated, which a lot of them have this week.”
Curling Canada revealed in 2023 that the prevailing model for the nationwide playdowns will definitely keep in place with following interval.
“If any changes are made, they would begin in the next (Olympic) quadrennial,” an organization spokesperson acknowledged by way of e-mail.
Another fascinating model peculiarity adopted Alberta’s Brad Jacobs went a super 8-0 in round-robin play and after that shed his very first certifying online game.
That required him proper right into a circumstance the place his solely path to a title will surely be 4 straight must-wins within the playoffs.
Jacobs took care of to attract it off with a 7-5 semifinal achieve Gushue on Sunday mid-day and a 5-3 success over Manitoba’s Matt Dunstone at evening final.
ENJOY|Jacobs and Team Alberta win 2025 Brier on wonderful final shot:
Trailing with the final rock within the final finish, Brad Jacobs pressed in a superb shot to rack up 3 and downMatt Dunstone’s Team Manitoba
“At the end of the day, there’s certain games you can’t lose,” Laing acknowledged. “I don’t know all of the solutions.
“The old style was a great deal easier, that’s for certain.”
