With court docket selection underway for her 2nd homicide check within the fatality of Boston Police Officer John O’Keefe, legal professionals for Karen Read are interesting a decreased court docket’s judgment that she is just not coping with twin threat to the united state Supreme Court.
Read’s preliminary check completed with a mistrial in 2015, but her authorized representatives have truly steered that the court docket concurred with one voice that she was harmless of two of the three prices, consisting of one of the extreme of homicide, which sustaining these on guides for her 2nd check is unconstitutionally positioning her on check two instances for the very same legal exercise.
This association was unannounced at check, nonetheless.
PROBE OF COMMUNITY AUTHORITIES IN KAREN READ INSTANCE DISCOVERS NO INDICATOR OF ‘CONSPIRACY TO FRAME’ SLAIN POLICEMAN’S PARTNER
Karen Read departures Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham, Massachusetts, on Wednesday, April 2, 2025. (Dario Alequin for Fox News Digital)
According to the 149-page declaring, Read’s authorized representatives exist the excessive court docket with 2 inquiries:
- Whether a final and consentaneous, but unannounced, selection by a court docket adhering to check that the prosecution fell brief to verify an accused responsible of a billed infraction includes a pardon averting retrial underneath theDouble Jeopardy Clause
- Whether an accused that generates reliable proof of such a final, consentaneous, and unannounced pardon is certified to a post-trial listening to to verify the reality of such pardon.
KAREN READ AND JOHN O’ KEEFE: INSIDE ADVANCEMENT OF BOSTON MURDER ENIGMA CONSIDERING THAT JULY MISTRIAL
Officer John O’Keefe postures for his principal headshot. O’Keefe’s companion, Karen Reed, is presently on check for homicide after he was situated useless exterior a Massachusetts house in January 2022. (Boston Police Department)
The Fifth Amendment assurances constitutional protection from coping with twin threat– check or penalty for the very same infraction two instances.
After a mistrial, a retrial can normally proceed– but Read’s authorized representatives recommend the particular situations in her occasion location her underneath twin threat on each prices jurors settled on but didn’t introduce.
GO BELOW FOR COMPLETE INSURANCE COVERAGES OF THE 2ND KAREN READ TEST
Karen Read and John O’Keefe place in an undated picture. (Karen Read)
Over days of delayed issues, jurors persistently despatched out notes to the court docket describing they went to a impasse, and Judge Beverly Cannone suggested them to keep up making an attempt. Deliberations began on June 25, 2024. By July 1, with jurors nonetheless deadlocked, the court docket acknowledged a mistrial.
In their allure, Read’s authorized representatives acknowledged the court docket didn’t supply steering for both facet the possibility to speak and disregarded the court docket with out asking in the event that they have been secured on all prices or any sort of prices independently.
KAREN READ COURT OPTION: DOZENS IN SWIMMING POOL ALREADY HAVE AN POINT OF VIEW ON THE INSTANCE
Karen Read beings in court docket all through court docket selection at Norfolk County Superior Court on Thursday, April 18, 2024 in Dedham, Massachusetts, for her preliminary check. (David McGlynn/New York Post by means of AP, Pool)
The following day, a juror acknowledged as Juror A spoken to Read’s lawyer, Alan Jackson, and knowledgeable him that the panel had “unanimously agreed that Karen Read is not guilty of Count 1 (second-degree murder),” in keeping with the authorized motion.
Text messages allegedly despatched out from Juror B shared comparable insurance coverage claims, in keeping with the authorized motion. Jurors C and D moreover linked to Read’s group with comparable variations of events, in keeping with the declaring.
Additionally, a minimal of 1 juror acknowledged it in a voicemail for district attorneys.
FOLLOW THE TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
Karen Read grins as protection lawyer David Yannetti talks to press reporters earlier than Norfolk Superior Court after the court docket acknowledged a mistrial after jurors weren’t capable of get to a judgment adhering to a two-month check on Monday, July 1, 2024 in Dedham, Massachusetts. ( AP Photo/Steven Senne)
“It was not guilty on second degree,” Juror B created in a message proven an extra Read lawyer,David Yannetti “And split in half for the second charge…I thought the prosecution didn’t prove the case. No one thought she hit him on purpose or even thought she hit him on purpose.”
In a phone name, Read’s authorized representatives assert Juror B cleared up the 2nd sentence of that message, stating it must have checked out, “No one thought she hit him on purpose or even knew that she had hit him.”
REGISTER TO OBTAIN REAL CRIMINAL OFFENSE E-NEWSLETTER
Judge Beverly Cannone examines the judgment slide the jurors must fill in after they get to a judgment in Karen Read’s homicide check on Wednesday, June 26, 2024 at Norfolk Superior Court in Dedham, Massachusetts. (Greg Derr/The Patriot Ledger by means of AP, Pool)
The homicide price was “off the table,” in keeping with the declaring, and Juror A likewise acknowledged jurors concurred that Read was harmless of leaving the scene.
Read was detained on prices of intoxicated driving, wrongful loss of life and leaving the scene of a mishap, and afterward fingered for the service cost of second-degree homicide after she presumably backed proper into O’Keefe exterior an occasion and repelled, leaving him to go away on the bottom in a snow storm.
If her allure succeeds, she would definitely merely cope with the wrongful loss of life price.
Karen Read reveals up together with her legal professionals, Alan Jackson and David Yannetti, all through the preliminary day of court docket selection at Norfolk Superior Court on Tuesday, April 1, 2025 in Dedham, Massachusetts. (Nancy Lane/The Boston Herald by means of AP, Pool)
GO HERE TO OBTAIN THE INFORMATION APPLICATION
Appellate courts in Massachusetts have truly at the moment refuted her demand, discovering that on account of the truth that no judgment had truly learn in court docket, she was not acquitted of any sort of prices and isn’t coping with twin threat. Her lawful group reworked to the nation’s highest attainable court docket at the moment, asking to judge a decreased court docket’s selection and for a post-trial listening to on the problem.
Read would possibly cope with life behind bars if based responsible of second-degree homicide at her 2nd check, which beganTuesday She has truly begged harmless and refuted participation in O’Keefe’s fatality, together with her safety providing her as a scapegoat being mounted by the claimed actual awesomes.
